AFPLONDON (AFP-Jiji) — Pep Guardiola said VAR will only be worthwhile if decisions taken by the controversial system are always correct after Manchester City’s 5-0 win at West Ham was interrupted by several replay reviews.
Guardiola’s side kicked off its Premier League title defense with a confident display as Raheem Sterling’s hat trick and goals from Gabriel Jesus and Sergio Aguero demolished the Hammers.
But City’s ruthless finishing wasn’t the main talking point in east London as VAR made a first major impact on a Premier League match.
The Video Assistant Referee technology is being used in the Premier League for the first time this season after featuring in the F.A. and League Cups in England last term.
The system was given quite a workout at the London Stadium, with several decisions reviewed, including City’s Jesus having a goal disallowed for offside against Sterling, while Aguero was able to score a retaken penalty after his initial saved spot kick featured West Ham encroachment.
There was also VAR approval for Sterling’s second goal and an early West Ham penalty appeal was turned down by the system.
The offside decision against Sterling was extremely close, and Guardiola disagreed with the call, insisting the constant interventions are only worth the hassle if they are always right.
“Only what I wish is that VAR doesn’t make mistakes, please. When it’s offside, it’s offside; when it’s a penalty it’s a penalty,” he told reporters.
“Rules are rules, no problem. But I will be upset if it’s something that is right and it’s disallowed. Then it will be not good.
“The only thing I’m concerned is when VAR makes a mistake. It happened quite often in the past, then it is better for the referee to make decision.”
Guardiola has already experienced the agony of VAR overturning a key decision when Sterling last season had what would have been a last-gasp Champions League winner against Tottenham ruled out for offside.
Since then, the Spaniard has joined the rest of his Premier League managerial counterparts for a VAR demonstration in London.
He remains hopeful the system will prove to be fairer in the long term, even if it needs to be quicker to make decisions after both teams had returned to their kickoff positions before Jesus’ goal was eventually disallowed.
“After what happened against Tottenham in the quarterfinals last season, we were there, 60,000 people jumping with joy, then one second later we lost because it was offside.